Serious question, has anyone actually used a public records request to fight a vague local speech rule?
Tbh I think our city code's rule on 'disorderly conduct' at public meetings is way too broad, and I'm not on the side of the people who say just deal with it. It bans 'intimidating or disruptive' speech and that language has no clear line, so a guy holding a sign outside a council meeting in Rochester got threatened with a citation last week for basically standing there. What actually worked for me was filing a records request for every citation issued under that section in the last 4 years, and the city clerk turned over 11 pages in about 9 days for a $32 fee. Almost none of them held up and the ones that did were for actual threats, not signs. That gave me real numbers to bring to the meeting instead of just arguing about feelings, and two council members admitted the wording was sloppy. I'm not saying it's a magic fix, but it beats yelling from the back row. Has anyone else gone the records route on a local speech rule and actually gotten a response before the next meeting?