Warning: a dispatcher in Ohio talked me out of an enclosed carrier and I still think about it
I shipped my car from Cleveland to Phoenix last year and had already put down a deposit on an enclosed carrier. A dispatcher named Ray called me before pickup and flat out said I was wasting money, that my car was a 2014 sedan worth maybe $9,000 and enclosed is for show cars and classics. He said open carriers move 7 to 9 cars at once so the price drops fast, and he quoted me $850 open versus $1,450 enclosed for the same route. I argued with him for ten minutes because I had read all the scary stuff about rock chips and dust. He told me to stop reading forums and go look at the top of my own hood. I switched to open and the car showed up in Phoenix in 4 days with one small chip on the bumper that I honestly can't tell from the ones already there. Now when people ask me about shipping I tell them open is the right call unless the car is actually worth protecting, and I mean actually, not just because you like it. What is the cutoff for you, at what car value does enclosed stop being a waste?