Hot take: I was wrong about pocket screws after 12 years of cutting dovetails by hand
A cabinet maker in Fort Worth showed me his drawer boxes last Tuesday and they were held together with pocket screws, tight and square after 6 years of daily use. Now I'm second guessing why I spent so long cutting dovetails on shop cabinets, anyone else make this switch?
Six years is nothing for a drawer box though. Pocket screws can pull loose over time since the screws are holding in end grain, and hand cut dovetails will outlast them by decades. Maybe it works for his shop but I would not bet a customer's kitchen on it.
Man, six years without a single failure is a pretty solid test run though. Pocket screws in end grain aren't as weak as people make them out to be if you drill pilot holes right and don't overtighten. Sounds like his boxes are holding up fine, so I'm not sure the sky is falling here.