Can we talk about haggling at the Hongqiao market? My wife says walk away, I say hold firm
My wife and I were at the big market near Hongqiao in Shanghai last month and we had two totally different ways of dealing with the sellers. She thinks you should give your price once, and if they say no, you just smile and walk away because they will usually call you back. I think you should stand there and go back and forth a few times, because the guy selling me a tea set started at 380 yuan and I got him to 140 by just not leaving. The thing is, her way works too, maybe even better, and we argued about it the whole ride back to the hotel. I still feel like the back and forth is part of the fun and the point, not a waste of time. But she keeps saying I paid too much because I did not walk, and honestly I am not sure who is right. How do you all handle it, one firm offer then walk, or stay and haggle it out?
Price you started at matters more than how you play it. Once the seller throws out the opening number, that is the real fork in the road, because a low start means the back and forth moves fast and you both land somewhere sane, while a crazy high start means every round is just clawing back toward reality. Your tea set guy opened at 380, so 140 was probably near the floor anyway and standing there felt like a win. A guy who opens at 900 for the same set can be worn down to 140 too, but only if you stay long enough, and your wife's walk-out trick tends to beat a long grind on those. So the two of you are both right, just about different sellers. Next time watch the opening number before you pick a style.