My writing group's 10 minute prompt turned into a 3 hour argument about a talking dog
Last Tuesday at the Panera on Route 9 in Hadley, our little writing group did a 10 minute prompt where you had to write from the point of view of an animal. I wrote about a golden retriever who works as a mall security guard and takes his job way too seriously. I thought it was a silly warm-up, but then Diane read hers about a dying cat and the whole table went quiet for like 30 seconds. Next thing I know, we are spending an hour debating whether a talking dog counts as a gimmick or a real character choice, and Mark pulled out a notebook to list the rules for when animal narrators work. By the end we had 6 pages of notes and nobody had finished their actual story for next month. I am still not sure if that prompt made us better writers or just better arguers. Does your group have one prompt that always starts a fight, or is it just us?