My sister swore I'd hate the ending of our October pick, and boy did I prove her wrong
We picked a book for October that everyone in my club swore was a slow burn, and my sister kept telling me the twist at the end would ruin the whole thing for me. I went into it ready to argue, took notes on every chapter like some kind of lawyer, and by page 200 I was sure she was dead wrong. Then the last 30 pages hit and I sat in my kitchen at 11pm just staring at the wall, totally got it. The worst part is she knew because she'd watched me do the exact same thing with two other picks over the past year, always so sure the story was going one way. Now I have to eat crow at our next meetup on the 12th and admit her read on the book was better than mine. Has anyone else had a club member call your reaction to a book before you even read it? How do you even come back from that?
The "eat crow at our next meetup" part is where I'd push back a little. Why does it have to be a loss for you? Your sister didn't read the book for you, she just watched how you read. That's not the same as having a better read on the story, it's more like she knows your habits better than you do. Going in with a notebook ready to argue probably made you dig in even harder, which is exactly why she saw it coming. Half of the fun for her is probably watching you fight the current before you give in, so I'd just own it and give her the win on the prediction while keeping your own take on the book.