I finally got a mod to reverse a 30 day ban by quoting the rule back at him, on a Tuesday no less
Got yanked from a local fishing forum in Toledo for calling a guy's boat trailer setup "sketchy," which isn't even a banned word, so I copied the mod's own pinned rules into an appeal and asked which line I broke, and 2 hours later he said "fair point" and flipped it back, but now I'm wondering if anyone else has won an appeal by doing that or did I just get a guy in a good mood?
My buddy ran into almost the same thing on a car audio group last year. He got a 2 week mute for telling a guy his wiring job was a fire waiting to happen, which honestly it was. He pasted the group's own rule list into the appeal and just asked which one he broke, and the mod let him back in the next day with some line about how he respected the effort. From what he told me the mods usually just skim appeals and a lot of them cave once you make them actually go read their own rules. Maybe not every mod will budge, but it seems like a solid play when the rule was never clear to begin with. Your case probably was a mix of both, a decent argument and a guy who wasn't in a bad mood that day.