Hot take: 2FA on everything is overkill and I'm tired of pretending it's not
I set up an authenticator for a pizza rewards account last week and realized I've got 34 codes in the app now, and honestly half of them protect nothing worth stealing, so where do you all draw the line on which logins actually get a second factor?
Think about what the code is actually protecting, not the account itself. A pizza app login can't do much damage on its own, but if that same email and password unlocks your bank or your main email, then the pizza app is the weak door into the house. So my rule is to check whether an account can be used to reset or reach something that matters. If yes, it gets a code even if it looks silly. If the login is a dead end with nothing behind it, skip it.
Oh man, the reset angle is what got me too. I started checking "forgot password" on the random sites instead of the site itself, since that shows where the email actually goes. Total game changer, way less guessing.